Season 5 Episode 2, Pretty Little Liars Recap, Whirly Girlie

Season 5 Episode 2, Pretty Little Liars Recap
Season 5 Episode 2, Pretty Little Liars Recap
Season 5 Episode 2, Pretty Little Liars Recap
Pretty Little Liars Recap Season 5 Episode 2
Episode Highlights:

In this PLL recap, Alison returns to Rosewood and spins a convoluted web of lies; Aria cries over Shana Whatsherface; Mama DiLaurentis is DEAD DEAD DEAD.

Episode Grade: A (Loved it!)
Alison is planning to run away from Rosewood AGAIN.

The pretty little liars are convinced that they're completely safe from A's threats now.

Alison’s police confession LULZ
Alison's return is met with surprisingly little fanfare.
Who doesn't already know that Alison DiLaurentis is alive!?
The pretty little liars take on Abbey Road.
Alison is just winging it in her police confession.
The police have photographic evidence of Alison's existence.
Alison DiLaurentis is spinning a web of lies.
The pretty little liars are blindsided by Alison's lies. They are living on Planet Ali.
Emily is still absolutely loyal to Alison.
Alison and Spencer are close to a catfight!
Alison received a text message from A, threatening her not to confess to the police.

Toby’s hairtrocity
Alison threw down a roll of toilet paper to Emily.
Veronica gets a new hairdo every time something bad happens to her daughter.
Toby's new hair looks like a mop.
I can't focus on the plot when Toby's hair is right there!
Veronica x Wren sexual tension continues to escalate! #WRENONICA
Let's hope Toby's hair is in a better state in his pubic area.
Aria’s haunted playlist
Shana's death is inconsequential to Aria.
Aria's playlist is haunted by Shana's undead ghost.
Aria Montgomery is suppressing an urge to kill again!
Why does Aria care about killing Shana so much. It's not that big of a deal.
Mike Montgomery is getting hotter this season! He bulked up!
I wanna give Alison a hug! *sobs*
Mona is handing out whistles and pretending to care about Alison.
Alison and Mona have a heated face-to-face confrontation!
Mona has been a lot eviller than Alison, am I wrong?
Alison visits her own grave. *awkward*
Alison gets emotional with her daddy.
Alison's emotional vulnerability is a highlight of this season so far.
Papa DiLaurentis is single and ready to mingle~ ;)

Jason vs. the bitchy animal shelter lady
There is so much shade on Jason's face! SYMBOLISM!
I can barely see Jason's beautiful face because he's covered in shadows.
Jason is creepily stalking his little sister while she sleeps.
The pretty little liars are desperate to accuse Jason of murder.
Hanna has to change her underwear after a close encounter with Jason.
Emily tells a terrible lie about a sublet.
THEORY: Kenneth DiLaurentis killed Jessica DiLaurentis.
Alison gets a new dog named Pepe!
Kathy the bitchy animal shelter lady is aggressively hostile towards Jason.
New Theory: Pepe DiLaurentis killed Jessica DiLaurentis!
Jessica’s body is found
Where is Mama DiLaurentis!?
Hanna snoops through Jessica's email messages.
The dog dug up Jessica's dead body!
Jessica DiLaurentis is officially DEAD DEAD DEAD.
Aria is not impressed with Mama DiLaurentis' death.
Jason is genuinely shocked that his mother is dead.
Poor Ali! Her mommy died just when she came back to life!
Read more recaps!

67 Responses

  1. Default avatar Sara July 5th, 2014 / Saturday

    5×02 was similar to 2×02. Jason was shady in 2×02,liars considered him as a suspect,and acted like bitches with
    HUGE NOSES and popped them everywhere :p

    I agree with Jason and liked the scene where he pretty much threatened Hanna and Emily for acting like
    PINOKIO :D And its an old trick of pll makers to make
    someone look like a suspect if they are innocent ! I mean
    seriously, stop giving the most handsome and interesting character a shitty storyline !!!! Two fathers,one dead mother and three ”unique” sisters, and all of them are either mean and sketchy or crazy! what a family this dude has..hah

    • Default avatar Recap Everything July 7th, 2014 / Monday

      Ahhh, I didn’t notice the parallels between those two episodes! It has been a long time since they’ve cast doubt onto Jason’s character~ I think his role in this show is better served as *eye candy* than *murder suspect* tho. :D

      With a family like Jason’s, i’m surprised he didn’t turn out MOAR CRAZY tbh.

  2. Default avatar Darkangel July 5th, 2014 / Saturday

    I love Alison. I’ve changed, I want redemption. Immediately lies and makes the liars part of her lie so they are stuck covering for her. Just like always. Even Spencer saying I’m not going to put up with this crap anymore, then puts up with her crap except this time she yells at her about it. Action speaks louder than words, Spence.

    Haha at Emily being the First Disciple of Alijesus. Her face in that pic you have is priceless. Alison, Mona and Jenna really are the holy trinity. They will get people to follow them to ends of the earth.

    So Jason’s back on the suspect merry-go-round. Not surprised, I think everyone’s been on there at least twice.

    Toby’s hair scares me. I think it might be A!

    • Default avatar Recap Everything July 7th, 2014 / Monday

      I’m so ready for the ~*Alison DiLaurentis Redemption Tour 2014~* – I think the best part about Alison’s character is that she’s incapable of being *completely* good, so she’s still a bit of a bitch even when she is supposed to be a Changed Woman. Her spinning a web of lies within 60 seconds of arriving back at Rosewood was such a classic Alison move. Can’t wait for her ringside bout with Spencer in the future. <3

      I worship the Holy Trinity of Alison, Jenna and Mona. It is my dream to see all three of them interacting together in a scene, as they plot and scheme and bitch against each other in the most diabolical ways.

      Basically yeah, they just go down the list of characters every season and make sure each person is accused of murder at least once. it's like a PLL tradition.

      Toby's hair scares me more than A, to be honest. >_<

  3. Default avatar DM July 5th, 2014 / Saturday

    “I’m sorry, I know this show has tackled some dark issues in the past, but I don’t think I’m ready to see ~*incestuous rape*~ on PLL just yet.”

    Is this show SO out of storylines that they actually ALREADY DID this yuck factor with Jenna and Toby? But I guess they weren’t ~actually~ siblings.

    • Default avatar Recap Everything July 7th, 2014 / Monday

      IKR? I think the PLL rule book states that if you have a half-sibling to a step-sibling on this show, incest is automatically implied. Jason’s is a special case though because he already macked on Melissa in the past, so if he does Alison and finishes off with Spencer, then he’ll get BINGO on his card.

  4. Default avatar Melody July 6th, 2014 / Sunday

    You do know Keegan was growing his hair out for charity right? I know you still make jokes and everything, but seriously give the guy a break. He was doing it for his mom. Loved the recap, as usual!

    • Default avatar Recap Everything July 7th, 2014 / Monday

      That’s so sweet of him. <3 Altho I still feel like he'd do his charity a whole lot more good if he just held a bake sale or donated in a fundraiser instead of growing that abandoned bird's nest on his head. #sorry D:

      P.S. I promise there won't be anymore digs at Toby's hairdon't for at least the next 2 recaps. *halo*

  5. Default avatar MVP July 6th, 2014 / Sunday

    HILARIOUS RECAP. Please please pretty please do season 1! I want to read your caustic comments on s1 Ezria drama! And Caleb and Hanna who were quite cute for like an episode or two. Also about evil Ian and Lucas the dork and Psycho Paige!

    Plus the storylines were so much better.

    • Default avatar Recap Everything July 7th, 2014 / Monday

      Season 1 is in the cards, I promise! I am back logged with so many PLL recaps since I am writing these at the pace of a snail! but it is my goal to write a recap for every PLL episode that ever existed~~~

  6. Default avatar Julia July 6th, 2014 / Sunday

    You’re back!

    Why does everyone think A is gone now?! I thought they knew there was an A-Team?! Weird…
    If the inevitable fight between Spencer and Alison, I’m totally team Spence, by the way.

    LOL @ Mrs. Hastings’ new hair do. When the stylist messes up, unfortunate implications arise. Maybe you should work as a consultant for PLL, since you clearly remember hairstyles over the seasons so much better. I’d vote for you!
    I also loved how they just had those random Spoby sex scenes thrown into the episode, like ~lalala, Aria has PTSD, Alison has so many problems I can’t even list them, but Spencer needs her daily dose of Toby. To be honest, if I were Spence, I would have done the exact same, and I actually think that these girls had way less trouble if all they did was go to school like normal teenagers and shtup normal teenage guys, but nooooo.

    I also LOL’ed really hard at Aria the Assassin. Once again, you are proving your wonderful talent to screencap in exactly the right moment, paired with your awesome captioning skills. You are my idol!

    Paige also seems to find Mona worse than Alison, if you watched episode four already. Ali’s just a bitchy mean girl, and yes, that can be awful to suffer from, but Mona is terrifying. Like, I’d move to get away from her.

    I don’t think we can blame the divorce of Mr. and Mrs. D on Alison. I mean, Mrs. D totally cheated on Mr. D with Spencer’s dad before Ali was even born?

    “You can’t fake that kind of emotion, man” Unless you’re an actor on Pretty Little Liars. Just sayin’. ;)

    Btw, I read the first of the PLL books! It has some hilarious lines in it, and it’s made even creepier by the fact that the girls where younger when Ali disappeared.

    Some quotes:

    So, Aria and Ezra almost have sex the first time she goes to his place. They decide not to do it, no one even needs a cold shower, and:
    “So then they’d snuggled up to each other, naked, and started to talk. Ezra told her about the time he was six and sculpted a red squirrel out of clay, only to have his brother squash it. How he used to smoke a lot of pot after his parents got divorced. About the time he had to take the family’s fox terrier to the vet to have her put to sleep. Aria told him about how when she was little, she kept a can of split pea soup named Pee as a pet and cried when her mom tried to cook Pee for dinner.”

    Or this one: Spencer and Wren are making out, until this happens:
    “Holy shit,” Spencer said. She held her T-shirt up against her naked chest.
    “What is it? Wren asked.
    Spencer stepped back. Her throat was dry. “Oh,” she croaked.
    “Oh,” Wren echoed.
    Melissa stood outside the window, her hair messay and Medusa-like, her face absolutely expressionless. A cigarette shook in her tiny, usually steady fingers.
    “I didn’t know you smoked,” Spencer finally said.

    Oh, and Hanna has an Adam’s apple. Is that a hint at something???

  7. Default avatar JOHN July 6th, 2014 / Sunday

    I died at the Alijesus part xD. This is my favorite episode of the new season thus far and this recap was equally fantastic.

    I hope you get out some more recaps very soon, as these things seriously make my day.

  8. Default avatar Kendall July 6th, 2014 / Sunday

    Lol about Toby’s hair! I was thinking the same thing while I was watching it xD

  9. Default avatar Pepe DiLaurentis July 7th, 2014 / Monday

    Brilliant recap, as always! *throws confetti*

    “What a cruel twist of fate for Alison to come back alive only for her own mother to die at exactly the same time. ”

    Wow. That reminds me of Game of Thrones season 3 with Arya and the Red Wedding.

  10. Default avatar Happs July 7th, 2014 / Monday

    “The most unrealistic part about their relationship is how we’re supposed to believe Mona’s black coal heart is capable of human emotions such as love”

    Blasphemy! Mona’s heart belongs to Hanna forever and always!

    • Default avatar SvL July 8th, 2014 / Tuesday

      Agreed. There’s too much chemistry between those two. Lol Mike, Hanna, AND Mona should hook up.

    • Default avatar Happs July 8th, 2014 / Tuesday

      The whole ‘Surfing the Aftershocks’ episode was like a big gay parade but Mona and Hanna really got into it.

  11. Default avatar Silhouette July 8th, 2014 / Tuesday

    Omfg! I was reading this during the 100th episode commercials and I literally had to pause the whole show once I started reading this beautiful peice of work. Jesus but the 100th episode was kinda funny. Ugh more aria and Ezra sh**, oh ‘great’ emily and Ali love, Caleb’s back, and somehow when I thought it couldn’t get any worse Spencer jst had to have her car moment with ugly Toby. Lol bitch slaps for Mona and Ali. It was only a matter of time before the show went all girly cat fight mode… On another note I loved how the liars and their loyal but completely shield from the truth boyfriends and exes all banded together like a group of detectives to watch the news. (Even though only half the detectives even know the clues) Jesus I can’t wait till u react to tht episode

    • Default avatar Julia July 9th, 2014 / Wednesday

      All of them watching the news together was so bizarre. Especially Hanna dragging Caleb with her.

    • Default avatar Silhouette July 9th, 2014 / Wednesday

      lol to Julia I loved the bizarreness of it tho

  12. Default avatar Concerned July 9th, 2014 / Wednesday

    I don’t know if you’ll read this, but I just watched the 100th episode and I’m disgusted. Sure, it was interesting and all, but PLL is a show watched mostly by teenage girls and they’re just giving the message that you get back together with a guy who used you and lied to you throughout your relationship? And don’t give me that “ooh he took a bullet for her TRU LUV” bullshit. Caleb took a bullet in the lighthouse too, but we don’t use that as an excuse to cover up all his flaws. I was disappointed in season 3 when Spencer forgave Toby but Aria is much worse. I mean we have 4 seasons of her living and breathing Ezra and just as she gets a little independent we stomp all over that? What will impressionable 15 year olds gather from this? I used to feel like Hanna and Caleb were the only healthy relationship on this godforsaken show but then he left her for a dead bitch and I guarantee you Hanna will just take him back like nothing happened. She’s already fawning all over him. I want my sassy Hanna back, NOT someone who forgives a guy at the drop of a hat.

    • Default avatar Silhouette July 9th, 2014 / Wednesday

      Thank you! That’s exactly what I’m thinking. I mean I don’t like Aria in the first place but she still shouldn’t keep going with him. I do t freaking care about Ezria forever and Spencer shouldn’t have forgiven Toby also. All of them just forgive their guys out of the fricken blue. I loved the hanna who hated men in the crazy old time film episode.

    • Default avatar robin July 9th, 2014 / Wednesday

      What’s even worse is that people on the internet are rejoicing at the return of this screwed up relationship. I feel like someone needs to yell at the Liars and slap the shit out of them until they stop being such incredibly stupid spineless bimbos. Caleb should do it now that he’s all dark. HEY BIFF GET A GRIP EZRA IS A CREEPY LIAR.

  13. Default avatar Darkangel July 9th, 2014 / Wednesday

    I think you should skip the next two eps and just do the 100th! That shit was da bomb! lolz

  14. Default avatar Recap Everything July 10th, 2014 / Thursday

    OMG. The 100th episode was PERFECTION~~~ Jenna’s return, Lucas’ imaginary girlfriend, Alison x Emily’s lesbian romp, Hanna leaping from one boy toy to the next, and of course THE SLAP (omg I lived and then died for THE SLAP). I will have a lot more to say about this episode when I recap it, but for now let us relive this glorious moment:

    • Default avatar Darkangel July 10th, 2014 / Thursday

      I love that Alison is so hardcore, when she slaps you, you bleed.

    • Default avatar Anonymous July 10th, 2014 / Thursday

      Her face tho and Lucas’ fakes girlfriend was almost as great as tht slap

    • Default avatar Julia July 11th, 2014 / Friday

      I watched that episode with my boyfriend, after making him read your recaps and explaining a lot about who’s who (his comment: “that’s a lot of suspicious characters!” XD), and when Mona cornered Ali in that church, I said to him, “if I were her, I’d totally tape this”, and voila, she did! Am I psychic or what? Maybe I’m A! *dudun* Kidding, this show is just pretty predictable.

      My boyfriend is a rather rational person, so watching PLL, he alternated between two comments (not counting “lololol”): “what the hell?!” and “why would anyone…?”

  15. Default avatar Mona July 17th, 2014 / Thursday

    Hey, Recap Everything! Can I ask you if you are a girl or a guy? Not knowing kinda drives me nuts ;P

  16. Default avatar Anon July 18th, 2014 / Friday

    When is the next recap? I can’t wait for the 100th episode.

  17. Default avatar sara July 21st, 2014 / Monday

    “Even effing Ezra knew about it and he’s basically just her fuck buddy. ” ezra and alison never had sex

  18. Default avatar Salad July 21st, 2014 / Monday

    WHERE ARE YE, LITTLE ONE? I check for new recaps every hour.

    • Default avatar Audrey July 21st, 2014 / Monday

      haha sammmeee (:

  19. Default avatar Audrey July 26th, 2014 / Saturday

    OHEMGEE GURRL this is getting rEALLY DIFFICULT. WE MISS YOU! three weeks without recaps is hurtin muh hart. (; hope to see you soon ~~

  20. Default avatar rebekah July 30th, 2014 / Wednesday

    After last night’s episode (5×09) I’m really looking forward to your comments about one particularly disappointing storyline, or rather, another extreme 180-shift in characterisation that makes little to no sense regarding a character I previously really liked!

  21. Default avatar Anon August 3rd, 2014 / Sunday

    omg not again

    • Default avatar Not Surprised August 4th, 2014 / Monday

      Didn’t we all see this coming, though?

    • Default avatar ANONOMAKASHJD August 5th, 2014 / Tuesday

      im confued.. what do you two mean?

  22. Default avatar The biggest Recapeverything fan August 5th, 2014 / Tuesday

    Hi, just wanna say I NEED MORE RECAPS NOOOOW!!! :)
    Season 5 is totally ridiculous by itself (even more than previous seasons and that says A LOT) so I’m totally looking forward for recaps. :)

  23. Default avatar Noah August 7th, 2014 / Thursday

    where did you go?!?!

    • Default avatar Recap Everything August 7th, 2014 / Thursday

      I am alive but I am currently undercover~~~ will get back to writing new recaps soon!

    • Default avatar Ross August 7th, 2014 / Thursday

      If not recaps then at least give us some snarky comments. I have dreams about your recaps.

  24. Default avatar Julia August 13th, 2014 / Wednesday

    I miss your recaps! Did you see yesterday’s episode? Have they run out of A videos or why did they make us watch them fold their laundry?! Did A mistakenly show us the video they had planned for their Martha Stewart-esque Youtube channel??

  25. Default avatar RE Reader August 19th, 2014 / Tuesday

    Please come back! You make this show wayyyyy better than it actually is!

  26. Default avatar Anonymous August 26th, 2014 / Tuesday

    Wtf not Mona WHY

    • Default avatar Recap Everything September 21st, 2014 / Sunday

      *holds a candlelight ritual for Mona*

      Sweet dreams, our little princess.

  27. Default avatar Anonymous August 29th, 2014 / Friday

    Ok, after this finale you HAVE to come back! I miss your recaps so much!!!

  28. Default avatar Anonymous September 2nd, 2014 / Tuesday

    We miss you!!! ;A;

  29. Default avatar Anonymous September 3rd, 2014 / Wednesday

    *sigh* another season came and went, and barely any recaps

  30. Default avatar K September 3rd, 2014 / Wednesday

    Gurl ~~ get off Planet Alison and come write some new recaps! I miss you!!!

    • Default avatar Recap Everything September 21st, 2014 / Sunday

      Help, Alison is holding me hostage on her planet and I can’t escape!!! D:

  31. Default avatar Erinsgirl September 7th, 2014 / Sunday

    Oh please post more recaps soon. I found this site like a month ago and I’ve read all the recaps at least twice. I want to see your takes on Season 1 and the Noir episode and Ali’s impressive time management skills in the Season 4 finale. How many girls can have threatening meetings with half the town in one night and still be involved in multiple murder attempts. It’s her true secret weapon.

    And I need your commentary to get the through two different tones of Season 5. Some of it was excellent. PLL’s biggest strengths are it’s characters and the ties they have to each other and showing the impact all this trauma has on them on their relationships with everyone in their lives. It grounds the show in a way. And it’s biggest weakness is skipping the emotional stuff to force in another convoluted twist and the payoffs always feel lacking because of it. They could have explored the girls relationships with Ali a bit more before red herring her as A.

    And can they please do something with the Love Interests beside a make-out scene. Sure if it’s a really depressing episode we need something to smile about but I’ve always liked Toby, Paige and Caleb because a) they seem reasonably competent and have proven to have eyes and brain cells to figure out their girlfriends are being stalked, b) despite having limited cash and resources and at most a high school education they actively try to help the girls without being asked, c) they seem to genuinely care about all the girls regardless of sleeping with them and d) despite being teenagers they still (usually) act smarter, more reasonable, and mature than other older college-educated characters. Ezra take note you’re a billionaire with high-level surveillance equipment and teenagers are still better at this than you. (And seriously why did Spencer only borrow a camera from him and not demand full access to all his files. He’s stalked her and accused her of murder. She’s earned a peek.)

    Which is why I need your recaps on Season 5 to help me recover from the painful and manipulative way the show is shoving Ezria down our throats again. The Toby-is-A/ Spencer-goes-crazy story line was by far the best thing about season 3 but the writers screwed it up at the end. Toby trying to protect the girls works with his character and getting accused of something he didn’t do is his primary reason to exist but the show completely ignored it. I want the show exploring why people join the A-Team (revenge, protection, blackmail, information, the kickass uniform, the great dental). Season 4 should have been Toby and Spencer understanding each others reasoning and Toby winning all the girls trust back (and thereby not the mom story line). To this day Spoby fans are still writing fanfics because they think the reconciliation was rushed and forced despite Toby staying a good guy. Ezria fans (from what I’ve seen) however believe a bullet fixes everything including being a useless, perverted, self-absorbed, sleazy creep. Aria literally went from I can’t trust him (5×11) to meet the family (5×12) between episodes that’s how lazy the writers got.

    I’m sorry for ranting so much but this is why you need to post new recaps so that I’m too busy laughing to type. Your recaps are saving everyone. You need to do your part in stopping A and me forcing my opinion on people who rightly couldn’t care. So pretty, pretty, please. In memory of our fallen Liar?

    • Default avatar Ruby September 7th, 2014 / Sunday

      I LOVE YOU.

    • Default avatar Anonymous September 8th, 2014 / Monday


    • Default avatar Julia September 17th, 2014 / Wednesday

      I agree so, so hard. Eza is a major creep, and not only that, he is outsmarted by high schoolers. I, like you, like Caleb, Paige and Toby a lot more when they’re not just love interests, but active parts of the story. How awesome was it when Paige just followed Alison in the semi-finale, instead of going all drama queen and barge into Emily’s room to accuse her of cheating? How great is it when Caleb takes one look at Hanna and her friends to know they’re lying? I can’t say much for Toby this season, because he’s been kind of annoying me. First his dead mama drama, which he drops the minute Spencer finds an actual lead, and then yells at her to quit it (WTF?), then his becoming a police officer while only going to the academy for like a week.

    • Default avatar Recap Everything September 21st, 2014 / Sunday

      I came back from the dead just to respond to this *EPIC* comment. Did you know I read this in my inbox a week ago and got so motivated to work on a PLL recap again? U rock. <3

      I will spew my many opinions on Season 5 in my upcoming recaps, but just to address a few of your insights:

      - *amen* on PLL is most compelling when it focuses on the emotional nuances of the storylines and the evolving relationship dynamics between the characters. This season has been good at depicting a more human side to the characters so that they seem more relatable (especially Alison), rather than them just being *dis crazy bitch* or *dat evil bitch* or *dose dumb bitches*. This characterisation enriches the storytelling because it makes us more emotionally invested in the characters and their journeys.

      - *amen* on the love interests needing more to do other than being the arm pieces for the pretty little liars. I think Ezra is a lost cause and probably insalvagable, but Caleb, Paige and Toby all have potential to be great support characters if they're given the right material to work with. I love your idea of retconning Season 4 so that it focused on Toby and Spencer working out their trust issues with each other, which would have been far more interesting to watch than whatever we got with the #deadmama trite.

    • Default avatar Erinsgirl October 28th, 2014 / Tuesday

      Just seeing you’re reply now. I’m so glad you liked it. I’m hoping this will encourage a new recap since I’m dying to see your take on the following (spoiler alert) :

      1) Caleb saved his soul and defeated the devil with fireflies? Rolls eyes. Although it does mean that A is now worse than the devil. Hmm:/. Explains a lot.
      Although I did find Toby completely ignoring Hanna hilarious. Actually all of 5×11 was really funny, but I’m not sure it was meant to be. Thoughts?

      2) Toby becoming a police officer. Pretty much what ran through my mind:
      a) This makes a degree of sense. At least by PLL levels. Will Toby actually get a plot line besides sticking his tongue down Spencer throat (and I’m a Spoby fan). Most of their dates involve investigations anyway.
      b) This is going to result in the girls/ Spencer being arrested isn’t it!
      c) A convoluted Spoby break-up due to being on other sides of the law is being forced on us right? Since going a season and a half without a break-up is sacrosanct in PLL (although given the shows timing it’ll last about an hour, even if we have to sit through several eps of some random guy hitting on Spencer before she’s back with Toby by the finale and therefore it’s absolutely pointless to care about any of it fan or not).
      d) Did Toby become a cop because Spencer seems to have a thing for authority figures/ uniforms?

      And of course I need to know your input for the really important things:

      3) Emily’s boobs love Christmas!

      4) The biggest contribution Ezra made in the finale was worrying about pie while Spencer was getting booked at the precinct. Sounds about right. (At this point I think he’ll be creepier if he actually starts being useful to the Liars).

      So thoughts, opinions? Recaps as an early Christmas present Recap Santa?:)

      Also do you agree/disagree with anything from the Fan Halloween Special. I grimaced through all things Ezra but some of it was quite interesting and Ian Harding pranking Shay Mitchell was hilarious.

    • Default avatar Erinsgirl October 29th, 2014 / Wednesday

      I would love to retcon alot of season 4 since I loved the Toby is A story line but hated the follow-through. There are so many others though.

      *The ridiculous masks that had no point.

      *Ezra being arrested (the it’s-all-a-dream-part, the scene itself is awesome.)

      *Also Marlene’s comment about specifically ensuring Aria was at the age of consent (there are so many things wrong with that!).

      *Ravenswood. The next PLL spin-off should be PLL:PI with Spencer, Hanna, Caleb and Toby running their own crime-fighting team. (Can you tell who my 4 fave are?) Musts include: Spencer commentary on all their targets actions, Hanna being Hanna and Ghost Mona giving her own insights and trolling everyone. With Cameos from Jenna, Melissa, Jason and Noel now and then purely to drive the gang nuts with their cryptic comments.

      Question if you could plan a PLL spin-off what would it be?

  32. Default avatar HOC September 8th, 2014 / Monday

    Forget it guys @RecapEverything is probably on the run now. Last time they saw her she was wearing a brunette wig and a redcoat.

    • Default avatar Recap Everything September 21st, 2014 / Sunday

      Oh no, my cover got unravelled! Now I have to get a new wig before they find me again!!!

  33. Default avatar Loyal Reader September 12th, 2014 / Friday

    These recaps make my day, and always put a smile on my face. I’m so grateful that you created this website, because it’s helped me feel better when I’m having a hard time, or just want to laugh. I hope you are doing okay, since we haven’t heard from you in a while. I miss your posts, but I respect that you have a real life and job, and are most likely too busy to watch tv and write recaps. That doesn’t change the fact that I miss you, though, and I hope you will be available in the future to write some more. You have some really loyal fans, and we can’t wait until your next masterpiece!

    • Default avatar Recap Everything September 21st, 2014 / Sunday

      This was such an incredibly sweet comment, thank you so much~ :)

      Considering that I post one new recap every three months, I really don’t deserve to have such loyal readers, but I am so immensely thankful that I do. I know that if I was in your shoes, I would have given up on this site long ago. That’s why I am always pleasantly surprised whenever I receive a new comment in my inbox during my long bouts of inactivity. And I do read all the comments even if I may not respond to them right away.

      I really love writing these recaps as well, and I’m glad most of you seem to enjoy them as well. It’s frustrating because there are so many things I wish I could be doing for Recap Everything – posting new recaps, replying back to your awesome comments, updating my social media feeds… Despite my best intentions, I don’t have the schedule to manage this site sometimes. However, I’m so grateful that whenever I return and work on a few new recaps, there are still a few devoted fans who stuck around to read my stuff. *sniffles sniffles* I feel so special~~~

  34. Default avatar PLLISLOVEPLLISLIFE October 6th, 2014 / Monday

    Omg the poll for the new toby do is just
    like 90% no way ew
    and 9% yes
    woooww hhahahaha

  35. Default avatar Emily January 30th, 2015 / Friday

    I like you and lol you

  36. Default avatar TT April 2nd, 2015 / Thursday

    I don’t mind Tobys hair being long but could please just put it in a different stlye

  37. Default avatar Sparia April 2nd, 2015 / Thursday

    Sparia forever

  38. Default avatar Sparia April 2nd, 2015 / Thursday

    Just because i couldnt leave aria

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Custom avatar Custom avatar Custom avatar Custom avatar Custom avatar Custom avatar Custom avatar Custom avatar Custom avatar Custom avatar Custom avatar